logicp 3 anni fa
parent
commit
e2418bfd59
2 ha cambiato i file con 29 aggiunte e 8 eliminazioni
  1. 4 4
      new/Hegel_OS.md
  2. 25 4
      new/Hegel_OS_notes.md

+ 4 - 4
new/Hegel_OS.md

@@ -545,7 +545,7 @@ At the centre of his metaphysics, as a speculative idealist are the ideas of soc
 #### Marxists.org: Absolute Idea
 "The absolute idea is both the apex and foundation of the philosophical system of Hegel. It includes all the stages of logic leading up to it, it is the process of development with all of its stages and transitions. The absolute idea, or "world spirit", plays the same kind of role for Hegel as a Deity. "History is the idea clothing itself with the form of events."
 
-"And Marx rejects the needs for any such concepts as history is a product of people, not the other way around. Like absolute truth, knowledge of the absolute idea is an attainable ideal. Representing the whole of nature which has developed to the point where it is conscious of itself. For the concept of nature to be developed to such a degree of concreteness that it has returned to itself, recollected itself if you will. An absolutely comprehensive, practical and concrete concept of the world. Hegel defines the absolute idea as the "unity of the theoretical idea and the practical idea". The theoretical idea is the completed notion or concrete concept of the world or action. The practical idea is the activity expressing this concept, practice. The unity of the two means fully conscious practice; people acting in true accord with own nature."
+"And Marx rejects the needs for any such concepts as history is a product of people, not the other way around. Like absolute truth, knowledge of the absolute idea is an unattainable ideal. Representing the whole of nature which has developed to the point where it is conscious of itself. For the concept of nature to be developed to such a degree of concreteness that it has returned to itself, recollected itself if you will. An absolutely comprehensive, practical and concrete concept of the world. Hegel defines the absolute idea as the "unity of the theoretical idea and the practical idea". The theoretical idea is the completed notion or concrete concept of the world or action. The practical idea is the activity expressing this concept, practice. The unity of the two means fully conscious practice; people acting in true accord with own nature."
 
 For whatever rejecting of Hegel's mysticism that Marx did, you can see that his instruction to wed theory to praxis, we just ran into conscious practice - praxis. His Instruction to wed theory to practice, which is maintained today in both Marxism and Neo-Marxism (as well as it appearing in woke literature and activism, especially in critical pedagogy in education and Critical Theory) - these all demand that this element of social activism is present to qualify as a Critical Theory. And all of this is readily derived from Hegel's idea of the theoretical idea and the practical idea.
 
@@ -624,9 +624,9 @@ The geist, in turn, is going to be able to refine how the prevailing ideas, usin
 No longer have an eternal God that is, but ideas as God, State as Son and Geist/culture as spirit. Rather than just being 3 in 1, we now have a spiraling process where one gives rise to an improved version of the previous. Spirling through history where a new improved state follows from the new improved ideas, usually through the activity of a "Man of Action" that is being used by history. Spiraling through history of ideas -> state -> spirit. Improving as they go along the trajectory of history. That's Hegelian metaphysics.
 
 ##### Trinity
-Not transcendent and eternal, but imminent and a process. It isn't - It's becoming. It isn't perfect - It's perfectable and perfecting through the process of history (heading towards the emergence or recollection ) of that philosophy perennis by speculation - msytically trying to recollect the prisca theologia. This is an alchemical approach to Trinity.
+Not transcendent and eternal, but imminent and a process. It isn't - It's becoming. It isn't perfect - It's perfectable and perfecting through the process of history (heading towards the emergence or recollection ) of that philosophia perennis by speculation - mystically trying to recollect the prisca theologia. This is an alchemical approach to Trinity.
 
-Philosophy is how this is going to be for Hegel (Reason/VErnunft), because that's how the geist informs the philosophers to improve the ideas, and the process through which Hegel recommends to do this is the Dialectic. Which is through seeking those contradictions but while keeping the essential core (Aufheben). THe reason for this is the alchemy that he based his thought on. It's also because he was a gnostic and he believed his ideas of reason were higher and understood things better. So, for Hegel, the God-Head isn't a thing that is in the world or is transcendent to the world, it's a process that spirals through and creates history as it goes.
+Philosophy is how this is going to be for Hegel (Reason/Vernunft), because that's how the geist informs the philosophers to improve the ideas, and the process through which Hegel recommends to do this is the Dialectic. Which is through seeking those contradictions but while keeping the essential core (Aufheben). The reason for this is the alchemy that he based his thought on. It's also because he was a gnostic and he believed his ideas of reason were higher and understood things better. So, for Hegel, the God-Head isn't a thing that is in the world or is transcendent to the world, it's a process that spirals through and creates history as it goes.
 
 Ideas give rise to a State, father begets son, this creates conditions for a spirit which then flows back into the father that was more self-aware than it was before. This unfolding of history and refinement of ideas are one and the same.
 
@@ -646,7 +646,7 @@ God doesn't become God until God realizes that he's God, which occurs only after
 
 ###### Christians
 - God Is
-- I am the I am. I am the alpha the omega. I am the thing that is before, beginning and after the end. Eternal perfect. God creates the worl dbecause it is his will as the creator to do so.
+- I am the I am. I am the alpha the omega. I am the thing that is before, beginning and after the end. Eternal perfect. God creates the world because it is his will as the creator to do so.
 
 ###### Hegelian metaphysics
 - Having the world and reflecting himself against the world, and refining the ideas of the world

+ 25 - 4
new/Hegel_OS_notes.md

@@ -373,7 +373,28 @@ Hegel -> Y Hegel -> Marxists -> Neo-Marxists -> Black Feminism
 
 ### Speculative Idealism
 - Ideas shape society thus refine ideas through speculative process
-- Must reach the Absolute Idea
-
-#### Absolute Idea
-- All stages of logic
+- Actualization of all ideas in perfected form
+
+#### Marxist's View of Hegel's Absolute Idea
+- The apex and foundation; all stages of logic
+- The same role as a deity
+- Unity of theoretical and practical
+- Criticized mystic nature of absolute idea, but still weds theory and practice to advance historicism towards escaton
+- Marx believed all men would hold the same idea at the end of history
+
+#### Theoretical and Practical Idea
+- Theory finds antithesis in the world through aufheben
+- Absolute is the final dialectical synthesis
+- Marx's analogous vehicle was praxis
+
+#### Trinity
+- History imperceptibly, and unstoppably moves forward
+- Moving to absolute idea
+- Seek contradictions and keep core
+- Idea is to State as Father is to Son; Son engages culture and causing wisdom to flow back to the Father (Geist) (self aware -> absolute)
+- Perfected society occurs when the Absolute Idea is fully synthesized
+- God created the world to compare against himself so the absolute idea could be realized; the abstract creates concrete but must become both abstract and concrete in order to be absolute
+- Hegel's God needs to create to realize himself, whereas the Christian God creates because it is his will
+
+**Forms of perfected syntheses:**
+- Marx Communism, Marcuse Libraion, Black Liberaion, Justice, Racial liberation